Commonwealth v. John Doe

ATTORNEY PATRICK J. NOONAN VACATES CONVICTIONS FOR RECEIVING A STOLEN VEHICLE, MALICIOUS DESTRUCTION OF PROPERTY, AND ATTEMPTED ESCAPE AGAINST 47 YEAR-OLD PLUMBER.

The client is a 47 year-old with no adult record of convictions and a resident of Cape Cod. He has been happily married for 20 years. For over 25 years, client has been a licensed union Plumber. He has been recognized for his volunteer charitable activities. The client applied for a License to Carry Firearms, which was denied because he had been convicted as a juvenile for the following offenses: Receiving a Stolen Motor Vehicle pursuant to G.L. c. 266, §28, Malicious Destruction of Property pursuant to G.L. c. 266, §127, and Attempted Escape pursuant to G.L. c. 268, §16. Because of his juvenile convictions, client was automatically disqualified from obtaining a License to Carry Firearms. Therefore, he needed to have all his juvenile convictions vacated, so he called Attorney Patrick J. Noonan.

Result: Attorney Patrick J. Noonan filed a Motion to Vacate the client’s juvenile convictions. Attorney Noonan argued that the offenses occurred a long time ago (approximately 32 years ago) when the client was at the tender age of 15 years old. Attorney Noonan cited research dealing with the development of the juvenile brain substantially affecting the child’s reasoning and judgment. At the tender age of 15, the client should have been treated as a child in need of rehabilitation instead of being treated as a criminal and punished. Attorney Noonan presented evidence showing that his client is now 47 years-old, happily married, a Union Plumber of 25 years, and has never been in any trouble since his youthful mistakes occurring over 30 years ago. The Commonwealth agreed that the client’s juvenile convictions should be vacated in the interests of justice. All convictions were vacated and all charges were dismissed. The client is now eligible to apply for an LTC.